Introduction and Background
The mission of the Office of the National Coordinator for Health IT (ONC) includes developing a health IT
infrastructure to promote safety, reduce medical errors, and increase quality and value in health care.
ONC supported that patient safety mission by commissioning the Institute of Medicine (IOM) to produce a
report in 2011: Health IT and Patient Safety: Building Safer Systems for Better Care.i The report recommended
a number of actions which, when implemented, would result in a learning health system that leverages health
IT to provide safer, better care. The IOM stated that “shared responsibility” among public and private sector
stakeholders for the safety and safe use of health IT is essential.
Building on the IOM Report, ONC released the Department of Health and Human Services’ Health IT Patient
Safety Action and Surveillance Planii (Health IT Safety Plan) in July 2013, which identified strategies to achieve
two core objectives: 1) use health IT to make care safer, and 2) continuously improve the safety of health IT.
In April 2014, ONC, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and the Federal Communications
Commission (FCC) published the congressionally mandated FDASIA Health IT Report, Proposed Strategy and
Recommendations for a Risk-Based Framework.iii The draft report identified the potential creation of a Health
IT Safety Center as a key non-regulatory component of an effective risk-based framework for health IT safety.
For health IT not currently regulated by the FDA, the FDASIA draft report suggested four priorities: promote
the use of quality management principles; identify, develop, and adopt standards and best practices; leverage
conformity assessment tools; and create an environment of learning and continual improvement. The FDASIA
draft report envisioned a Health IT Safety Center as a public-private entity that helps create a sustainable,
integrated learning system for health IT safety that would promote innovation and leverage and complement
existing and ongoing safety initiatives.
Health IT Safety Center Road Map Project
Based on this work, in September 2014, the ONC contracted with RTI International to develop a Road Map for
a potential Health IT Safety Center. As a central component of this work, RTI has convened a Task Force of
private-sector stakeholders to provide input into the development of the Road Map. Representatives from
ONC, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), the FDA, the FCC and, as appropriate, other
Federal agencies will also participate in the Task Force.
Defining Core Health IT Safety Center Objectives and Functions in the Road Map
In developing the Road Map, the Task Force will be asked to prioritize the value of potential core activities, as
well as to consider options for governance and for funding mechanisms/levels for a Health IT Safety Center.
Initially, the focus will be on health IT-related clinical processes that rely upon interoperable certified
electronic health record technology, although that focus may broaden over time. Table 1 provides a broad
summary of operational considerations for a potential Health IT Safety Center. The Task Force may consider
other factors that might strengthen the Health IT Safety Center’s value proposition and engage private-sector
stakeholders in ways that support (and do not supplant) private-sector health IT safety initiatives and
Table 1. Operational Considerations for the Health IT Safety Center Road Map
Potential Core Activities
Provide educational programs about research and activities, including programs by key stakeholders.
Promote opportunities for engagement in health IT-related safety activities and programs in the public and private sectors.
Analyze evidence on health IT safety and safety tools/interventions, including producing periodic written reports on:
- research on types, severity, and frequency of health IT-related events, and related methodology and
- research on specific priority areas related to health IT safety;
- identification and evaluation of tools and interventions intended to mitigate risks of the use of health IT or that use health IT to make care safer; and
- identification of gaps in the research or the need for development or refinement of tools/interventions that could improve health IT safety or use health IT to make care safer.
Foster health IT safety research and practical, actionable tool/intervention development in the private sector and by government.
Identify health IT safety goals, priorities, and related measures to help align and harmonize public- and patient safety in health IT-enabled environments.
Encourage stakeholders to: (1) measure and evaluate progress toward identified goals, and (2) share learning about making health IT safer and using health IT to improve patient safety.
Provide a forum for private-sector stakeholders and Federal Government representatives to dialogue
and work together.
Consider options for a governance structure that promotes effective engagement by private-sector stakeholders and by ONC, AHRQ, FDA, and other Federal entities, and that ensures balance in prioritization and decision-making that supports the public interest.
Discuss options for membership or other forms of participation that promote a broad base of stakeholder engagement, support, and input as well as options for how to build that broad base.
Funding Mechanism and Levels
Consider the implications of different funding mechanisms, including contracts and grants (including a cooperative agreement).
Consider the potential for private-sector funding of prioritized activities.
Given prioritized activities, identify those activities that may be best funded through the Health IT Safety Center and activities that could be funded outside of a Center by ONC, AHRQ, or others.
Provide an estimate of the total annual cost to operate an optimal Health IT Safety Center and related activities for each of its first 5 years of operation, based on prioritized activities (identified through the Road Map process) at funding levels equivalent to 75 percent, 50 percent, and 25 percent of the optimum level.
Boundaries on Scope of Activities
For the purposes of this Road Map, the activities for a Health IT Safety Center are focused on activities that are consistent with ONC and AHRQ’s missions and authorities. As such, we anticipate that the Health IT Safety Center:
Will not engage in direct investigation or surveillance.
The Health IT Safety Center could promote ways to better identify and investigate health IT-related events and unsafe conditions within healthcare organizations, often with support and expertise provided by outside organizations, such as Patient Safety Organizations (PSOs), accrediting organizations, and technology developers.
Will not include operating or funding the operations of a PSO.
- The Health IT Safety Center could be based in a larger entity that operates a component PSO.
- ONC and AHRQ can fund studies and the development of best practices and tools by PSOs.
Will not include direct data collection.
- The Health IT Safety Center could draw on analysis and evidence from private sector databases, subject to the willingness and ability of the private sector to share within applicable laws and legal obligations.
- The Health IT Safety Center could use data from public data sources, such as FDA’s Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience (MAUDE) database, AHRQ’s Network of Patient Safety Databases (NPSD), and ONC’s Certified Health IT Product List (CHPL), among others.
Will not include performing functions of Federal Advisory Committees.
- ONC’s Health IT Policy and Health IT Standards Committees and the National Committee on Vital Health Statistics are Federal Advisory Committees that advise the Secretary on these and similar matters.
Will not include activities that are exclusively the responsibility of federal entities, and, therefore, cannot be delegated to outside parties, such as the exercise of regulatory authority, establishing government programs, and decision-making related to federal budget expenditures and priorities.
Task Force Management
RTI is responsible for assembling the Task Force, ensuring that the membership provides a representative voice from major stakeholder groups and that all perspectives are considered.
A set of standard operating procedures (SOPs) will ensure that Task Force members’ roles and responsibilities are clear, and that the processes for engaging members, facilitating discussions, and capturing member input are well documented. All stakeholders on the Task Force will have the opportunity to fully participate and comment on Road Map development. RTI’s facilitation practices focus on obtaining robust input from a variety of perspectives, such that no single perspective or small subset of perspectives dominates the discussion or
Leadership Structure of the Task Force
RTI will ask a small subset of Task Force members to serve on a Steering Committee, which will help plan meetings and give input to Task Force processes between meetings. Each Task Force member will be asked to serve on at least one of four smaller workgroups to discuss Road Map input in the general areas of functions and activities, research/evidence, and governance.
At any time RTI may adjust the membership of the Task Force, Steering Committee, or workgroups to ensure the development of a useful and grounded Road Map. RTI encourages Task Force members to attend all meetings, but may allow Task Force members to identify designees if they are unable to attend a particular meeting.
Health IT Safety Task Force Members
Terry Fairbanks, MD, MS
Director, National Center for Human Factors in Healthcare and MedStar SiTEL, MedStar Health
Executive Director, Alliance for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety
Richard Landen, MBA, MPH
QuadraMed, Director of Regulatory Affairs Representing the HIMSS Electronic Health Record (EHR) Association
Ronni Solomon, JD
Executive Vice President and General Counsel, ECRI Institute
Dean F. Sittig, PhD
School of Biomedical Informatics, University of Texas Health Science Center, Houston, TX
Tejal Gandhi, MD, MPH
National Patient Safety Foundation
Rebecca P. Snead, BSPharm
National Alliance of State Pharmacy Associations, Alliance for Patient Medication Safety
Steven Stack, MD
President-elect, American Medical Association
Diane Jones, JD
American Hospital Association
David Classen, MD
CMIO, Pascal Metrics; Associate Professor of Medicine, University of Utah
Gerard M. Castro, PhD, MPH
Project Director, Patient Safety Initiatives; Office of Patient Safety, The Joint Commission
Luke Sato, MD
Senior Vice President and Chief Medical Officer, CRICO/Risk Management Foundation
Gilad (Gil) Kuperman, MD, PhD
Director, Interoperability Informatics, NY-Presbyterian Hospital
Susan McBride, PhD, RN-BC, CPHIMS
Professor, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, School of Nursing
Shafiq Rab, MD
Hackensack University Medical Center Representing College of Healthcare Information Management Executives (CHIME)
Eugene Heslin, MD
Bridge Street Medical Group
Stephanie Zaremba, JD
Senior Director, Hospital Ratings, The Leapfrog Group
Michael Cohen, MD
Professor, Department of Pathology, University of Utah
Emily Barey RN, MSN (Alt: Jim Russell)
Director of Nursing Informatics, EPIC
David B. Troxel, MD
Medical Director and Secretary, Board of Governors, The Doctors Company
Martha Donovan Hayward
Institute for Healthcare Improvement, Public and Patient Engagement
Marilyn Neder Flack
Executive Director, Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) Foundation Senior Vice President, Patient Safety Initiatives
Bakul Patel, MSEE, MBA
Associate Director for Digital Health (Acting), Center for Devices and Radiological Health, Food and Drug Administration
Andrew Gettinger, MD
Office of Clinical Quality and Safety, Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology
Amy Helwig, MD, MS
Deputy Director, Center for Quality Improvement and Patient Safety, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality
Ben Bartolome (Alt: Yahya Shaikh, MD, MPH)
Special Counsel, Office of General Counsel, Federal Communications Commission
Center for Clinical Standards & Quality, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services